Skip to content
FiftyCalc Free calculators for all 50 states

Car Insurance Deductible Calculator

Test cases replayed : 2 of 2 match · Methodology · No outside source listed

Enter two deductible options with the yearly premium quoted for each, and how many claims you expect per year on that coverage. The calculator shows how long the premium savings take to cover the extra deductible and which option costs less on average.

Result

Sample figures

Lower expected yearly cost—

Premium saved per year with the higher deductible —

  • Extra paid out of pocket per claim—
  • Years without a claim to break even—
  • Claims per year above which the lower deductible costs less—
  • Expected yearly cost, lower deductible—
  • Expected yearly cost, higher deductible—

Estimate for planning only, not tax, legal, financial or medical advice. This calculator uses the method explained on this page.

Car Insurance Deductible Calculator

Lower deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 500.

Yearly premium with the lower deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,600.

Higher deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,000.

Yearly premium with the higher deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,450.

Claims you expect per year (0.1 = one every 10 years): enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 0.1.

How to use this calculator

Fill in the fields in this order; each step takes you to its field.

  1. Lower deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  2. Yearly premium with the lower deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  3. Higher deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  4. Yearly premium with the higher deductible, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  5. Claims you expect per year (0.1 = one every 10 years): enter 0 or more.
  6. Read the result: Lower expected yearly cost; the panel also shows Premium saved per year with the higher deductible, Extra paid out of pocket per claim, Years without a claim to break even, Claims per year above which the lower deductible costs less, Expected yearly cost, lower deductible and Expected yearly cost, higher deductible.

How this calculator works

Premium saved = premium with the lower deductible − premium with the higher one. Extra per claim = higher deductible − lower deductible.

Break-even = extra per claim ÷ premium saved per year: the claim-free years after which the savings have paid for one claim at the higher deductible.

Expected yearly cost = premium + claims per year × deductible. The threshold claims per year = premium saved ÷ extra per claim; above it, the lower deductible is cheaper on average.

The comparison assumes each claim is larger than the higher deductible and leaves out premium increases after a claim. Use quotes for the same coverage, driver and car; the claim frequency is your own estimate.

The formula

  1. Cl=pl+f×dl
  2. Ch=ph+f×dh
  3. B={1if Ch<Cl2if Ch>Cl0otherwise
Symbols used in the formula
SymbolMeaningUnit
dlLower deductible$
plYearly premium with the lower deductible$
dhHigher deductible$
phYearly premium with the higher deductible$
fClaims you expect per year (0.1 = one every 10 years)
ClExpected yearly cost, lower deductible$
ChExpected yearly cost, higher deductible$
BLower expected yearly cost

Worked example

Lower deductible$500
Yearly premium with the lower deductible$1,600
Higher deductible$1,000
Yearly premium with the higher deductible$1,450
Claims you expect per year (0.1 = one every 10 years)0.1
Premium saved per year with the higher deductible$150
Extra paid out of pocket per claim$500
Years without a claim to break even3.3
Claims per year above which the lower deductible costs less0.30
Expected yearly cost, lower deductible$1,650
Expected yearly cost, higher deductible$1,550
  1. Cl=1,600+0.1×500=1,650
  2. Ch=1,450+0.1×1,000=1,550
  3. B=1

Lower expected yearly cost Higher deductible

Each step uses the unrounded value of the step before it; figures on this page are rounded for display.

Frequently asked questions

Is a higher deductible always cheaper?

Its premium is lower, but you pay more when you claim. It saves money on average when you claim less often than the threshold shown, and only if you can pay the higher deductible when needed.

Does the deductible apply to liability claims?

Deductibles apply to coverage for your own car, such as collision and comprehensive. Check your policy declarations page to see which coverages carry one.

Can my lender limit my deductible?

If your car is financed or leased, the contract may set a maximum deductible. Check it before you raise yours.

Questions answered

Related calculators