Skip to content
FiftyCalc Free calculators for all 50 states

Loan Comparison Calculator

Test cases replayed : 3 of 3 match · Methodology · No outside source listed

Enter two loan offers to compare their monthly payments, total interest and total cost, upfront fees included.

Result

Sample figures

Lower total cost—

Loan A: monthly payment —

  • Loan A: total interest—
  • Loan A: total cost (interest + fees)—
  • Loan B: monthly payment—
  • Loan B: total interest—
  • Loan B: total cost (interest + fees)—
  • Difference in total cost (A − B)—

Estimate for planning only, not tax, legal, financial or medical advice. This calculator uses the method explained on this page.

Loan Comparison Calculator

Loan A: amount, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 25,000.

Loan A: interest rate, in % / year: enter a number from 0 to 100. Prefilled example: 7.5.

Loan A: term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 600. Prefilled example: 60.

Loan A: upfront fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 0.

Loan B: amount, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 25,000.

Loan B: interest rate, in % / year: enter a number from 0 to 100. Prefilled example: 6.9.

Loan B: term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 600. Prefilled example: 72.

Loan B: upfront fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 300.

How to use this calculator

Fill in the fields in this order; each step takes you to its field.

  1. Loan A: amount, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  2. Loan A: interest rate, in % / year: enter a number from 0 to 100.
  3. Loan A: term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 600.
  4. Loan A: upfront fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  5. Loan B: amount, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  6. Loan B: interest rate, in % / year: enter a number from 0 to 100.
  7. Loan B: term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 600.
  8. Loan B: upfront fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  9. Read the result: Lower total cost; the panel also shows Loan A: monthly payment, Loan A: total interest, Loan A: total cost (interest + fees), Loan B: monthly payment, Loan B: total interest, Loan B: total cost (interest + fees) and Difference in total cost (A − B).

How this calculator works

Each monthly payment uses the standard amortization formula: payment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), where P is the amount borrowed, r the annual interest rate ÷ 12 and n the number of months.

Total interest = payment × n − P. Total cost adds the upfront fees you enter (origination fee, points) to the interest, so two offers with different fees and terms can be compared on one figure.

A lower monthly payment can hide a higher total cost when the term is longer. Federal Truth in Lending disclosures (Regulation Z) give each offer's APR and finance charge. APR may include certain loan fees. This calculator uses the annual interest rate applied to the loan balance, not the APR. Enter that interest rate here and enter fees separately. Check which fees are already included in the figures provided by your lender to avoid counting them twice.

The formula

  1. Pa=pmt⁡(aa,ar1,200,an)
  2. Ia=Pa×an−aa
  3. Ca=Ia+af
  4. Pb=pmt⁡(ba,br1,200,bn)
  5. Ib=Pb×bn−ba
  6. Cb=Ib+bf
  7. B={1if Ca<Cb2if Cb<Ca0otherwise
Symbols used in the formula
SymbolMeaningUnit
aaLoan A: amount$
arLoan A: interest rate% / year
anLoan A: termmonths
afLoan A: upfront fees$
baLoan B: amount$
brLoan B: interest rate% / year
bnLoan B: termmonths
bfLoan B: upfront fees$
PaLoan A: monthly payment$
IaLoan A: total interest$
CaLoan A: total cost (interest + fees)$
PbLoan B: monthly payment$
IbLoan B: total interest$
CbLoan B: total cost (interest + fees)$
BLower total cost
pmt(P, r, n)the payment per period that repays P over n periods at rate r per period, or P ÷ n when r is zero.

Worked example

Loan A: amount$25,000
Loan A: interest rate7.5 % / year
Loan A: term60 months
Loan A: upfront fees$0
Loan B: amount$25,000
Loan B: interest rate6.9 % / year
Loan B: term72 months
Loan B: upfront fees$300
Loan A: monthly payment$500.95
Loan A: total interest$5,057
Loan A: total cost (interest + fees)$5,057
Loan B: monthly payment$425.03
Loan B: total interest$5,602
Loan B: total cost (interest + fees)$5,902
Difference in total cost (A − B)-$845
  1. Pa=pmt⁡(25,000,7.51,200,60)=500.949
  2. Ia=500.949×60−25,000=5,056.92
  3. Ca=5,056.92+0=5,056.92
  4. Pb=pmt⁡(25,000,6.91,200,72)=425.026
  5. Ib=425.026×72−25,000=5,601.85
  6. Cb=5,601.85+300=5,901.85
  7. B=1

Lower total cost Loan A costs less over its term

Each step uses the unrounded value of the step before it; figures on this page are rounded for display.

Frequently asked questions

Should I pick the loan with the lower payment or the lower total cost?

They answer different questions. The lower payment eases the monthly budget; the lower total cost is what the loan costs you over its life. A longer term usually lowers the payment and raises the total cost.

Why is the longer loan more expensive even at a lower rate?

Interest is charged every month on the remaining balance, so more months can add more interest than a slightly lower rate saves.

Questions answered

Related calculators