Skip to content
FiftyCalc Free calculators for all 50 states

Leasing vs. Buying a Car, What Is the Difference?

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), buying a car means that you own the vehicle once your payments have been made, while a lease is an agreement to use a vehicle for a certain number of months and miles. The CFPB says the most important factor to consider is that leasing is like renting, and your payments won't go toward owning the car, unless there's an option to purchase it. Unless there's an option to purchase it, you'll need to return the car once the lease ends. The CFPB answer quoted here was last reviewed on September 12, 2023.

Open the Lease vs Buy Car Calculator

How it is calculated

When you buy, your monthly payments for a loan may be higher than leasing, but your payment goes toward paying down your loan and equity in the vehicle. You can drive as many miles as you want, but high mileage and excessive wear and tear affect the vehicle's resale value. You own the vehicle and get to keep it at the end of the loan term, and you have the option to sell or trade it in when you want to purchase a new one. The CFPB says a typical auto loan term ranges from 3 to 7 years.

When you lease, your monthly payments may be lower than buying, but the payments are going toward depreciation of the vehicle during the lease term plus rental charges. You may be responsible for early termination charges if you end the lease early, and these fees can be very expensive. Most leases restrict your mileage to 10,000 to 15,000 miles per year, and they may also include fees for excessive mileage and for wear and tear at the end of the agreement. At the end of your lease term, you can either turn the vehicle in and pay any end-of-lease fees or purchase the vehicle if your lease includes a purchase option. A typical lease is two to four years.

With a standard lease, most of your monthly payment goes toward the amount that the vehicle depreciates over the lease term, and you also pay a monthly fee to the lender for renting the vehicle. In the CFPB's example, a negotiated cost of $20,000, minus any trade-in, down payment or rebate, and an $8,000 residual value give $20,000 − $8,000 = $12,000 of depreciation. The CFPB then writes $12,000 divided by 36 months = $333, a rounded amount for the depreciation alone, while its method for the monthly payment also adds the rent charge, taxes and fees. Lease terms are negotiable, and the items consumers most commonly negotiate include the cost of the vehicle, the residual value, the down payment, the trade-in value, the rental charge or money factor, the mileage limit and the purchase option.

In the calculator, you enter the lease offer, the price, down payment, rate and term of a loan for the same car, and the car's estimated value at the end of the lease term. It adds the amount due at signing to every monthly payment of the term, so a monthly payment already included in the amount due at signing would be counted again. Over the lease term, it counts the lease as the amount due at signing plus the monthly payments plus end-of-lease fees. It counts buying as the down payment plus the loan payments made plus the loan balance still owed, minus the car's estimated value at the end of the lease term, an estimate whether or not you actually sell the car. Both costs are in plain dollars, without any return on cash you keep, and with the same insurance and maintenance, and the resale value is your own estimate.

Worked example

Assumptions: a lease of 24 months with $2,000 due at signing, which includes none of the 24 monthly payments of $399, and no end-of-lease fees, against buying the same car for $30,000 with $3,000 down and a 5.5% loan over 48 months, and a resale value of $21,000 after 24 months; all of these figures are examples, not offers. The lease costs $2,000 + $399 × 24 = $11,576 over the 24 months. The calculator shows a loan payment of $627.92, a loan balance of $14,240 still owed after 24 months, and a net cost of buying of $11,310. Leasing costs $11,576 − $11,310 = $266 more in this example. This compares costs in plain dollars, without any return on cash you keep, and the result depends on the resale value you estimate. With a resale value of $18,000 instead, the net cost of buying rises to $14,310, so the result depends on the value you estimate.

Lease term, period compared24 months
Lease: due at signing$2,000
Lease: monthly payment$399
Lease: end-of-lease fees, disposition and charges$0
Buy: price with taxes and fees$30,000
Buy: down payment$3,000
Buy: loan rate5.5 % / year
Buy: loan term48 months
Buy: estimated car value at the end of the period$21,000
Lease cost minus buy cost (positive: buying costs less)$266
Net cost of leasing$11,576
Net cost of buying$11,310
Loan monthly payment$627.92
Loan balance left at the end of the period$14,240

Figures computed by this site's calculator from the inputs above. Run your own numbers: Lease vs Buy Car Calculator

Frequently asked questions

What are the pros and cons of leasing a car vs buying?

Lease payments may be lower than loan payments, but they go toward depreciation plus rental charges, and you return the car once the lease ends unless your lease includes a purchase option that you use. Loan payments may be higher, but they go toward paying down your loan and equity in the vehicle, which you keep at the end of the loan term.

Can you buy a car at the end of a lease?

Yes, if your lease includes a purchase option; the CFPB describes the residual value as what you will pay for the car in that case.

Sources

General information drawn from the official sources above, not tax or legal advice. Amounts change from year to year: check the source for your tax year.

Related

See all Car Loan & Car Payment Calculators