Skip to content
FiftyCalc Free calculators for all 50 states

Mortgage Comparison Calculator

Test cases replayed : 2 of 2 match · Methodology · No outside source listed

Enter the loan amount, then the rate, term, points and lender fees of two offers, as shown on their Loan Estimates.

Result

Sample figures

Loan B saves (+) or costs (−) over the full term—

Loan A: monthly payment —

  • Loan B: monthly payment—
  • Loan A: total interest—
  • Loan B: total interest—
  • Loan A: interest + points + fees—
  • Loan B: interest + points + fees—
  • Months for B's lower payment to repay its extra up-front cost—

Estimate for planning only, not tax, legal, financial or medical advice. This calculator uses the method explained on this page.

Mortgage Comparison Calculator

Loan amount, in dollars: enter 1 or more. Prefilled example: 350,000.

Loan A: interest rate, in percent: enter a number from 0.01 to 20. Prefilled example: 6.75.

Loan A: term

Loan A: term: choose 30 years, 20 years or 15 years. Prefilled example: 30 years.

Loan A: points (% of loan): enter a number from 0 to 5. Prefilled example: 0.

Loan A: other lender fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,500.

Loan B: interest rate, in percent: enter a number from 0.01 to 20. Prefilled example: 6.25.

Loan B: term

Loan B: term: choose 30 years, 20 years or 15 years. Prefilled example: 30 years.

Loan B: points (% of loan): enter a number from 0 to 5. Prefilled example: 1.

Loan B: other lender fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,500.

Affiliate link

This is an affiliate link: FiftyCalc may earn a commission from this link. This does not change the result.

Mortgage Research Network connects people with home loan lenders. Mortgage Research Network is not a government agency and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any U.S. federal agency. Visit Mortgage Research Network

How to use this calculator

Fill in the fields in this order; each step takes you to its field.

  1. Loan amount, in dollars: enter 1 or more.
  2. Loan A: interest rate, in percent: enter a number from 0.01 to 20.
  3. Loan A: term: choose 30 years, 20 years or 15 years.
  4. Loan A: points (% of loan): enter a number from 0 to 5.
  5. Loan A: other lender fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  6. Loan B: interest rate, in percent: enter a number from 0.01 to 20.
  7. Loan B: term: choose 30 years, 20 years or 15 years.
  8. Loan B: points (% of loan): enter a number from 0 to 5.
  9. Loan B: other lender fees, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  10. Read the result: Loan B saves (+) or costs (−) over the full term; the panel also shows Loan A: monthly payment, Loan B: monthly payment, Loan A: total interest, Loan B: total interest, Loan A: interest + points + fees, Loan B: interest + points + fees and Months for B's lower payment to repay its extra up-front cost.

How this calculator works

Each payment = L × r × (1 + r)^n ÷ ((1 + r)^n − 1). Total interest = payment × number of months − loan. One point costs 1% of the loan amount, paid at closing.

Break-even = (B's up-front cost − A's up-front cost) ÷ (A's payment − B's payment), in months. If you expect to sell or refinance before then, the loan with less paid up front is usually cheaper. A negative or missing break-even means one loan is cheaper both ways.

The formula

  1. P=pmt⁡(a,ra1,200,ta×12)
  2. Pay=pmt⁡(a,rb1,200,tb×12)
  3. I=P×ta×12−a
  4. In=Pay×tb×12−a
  5. C=I+a×pa100+fa
  6. Co=In+a×pb100+fb
  7. D=C−Co
Symbols used in the formula
SymbolMeaningUnit
aLoan amount$
raLoan A: interest rate%
taLoan A: term
paLoan A: points (% of loan)
faLoan A: other lender fees$
rbLoan B: interest rate%
tbLoan B: term
pbLoan B: points (% of loan)
fbLoan B: other lender fees$
PLoan A: monthly payment$
PayLoan B: monthly payment$
ILoan A: total interest$
InLoan B: total interest$
CLoan A: interest + points + fees$
CoLoan B: interest + points + fees$
DLoan B saves (+) or costs (−) over the full term$
pmt(P, r, n)the payment per period that repays P over n periods at rate r per period, or P ÷ n when r is zero.

Worked example

Loan amount$350,000
Loan A: interest rate6.75%
Loan A: term30 years
Loan A: points (% of loan)0
Loan A: other lender fees$1,500
Loan B: interest rate6.25%
Loan B: term30 years
Loan B: points (% of loan)1
Loan B: other lender fees$1,500
Loan A: monthly payment$2,270.09
Loan B: monthly payment$2,155.01
Loan A: total interest$467,234
Loan B: total interest$425,804
Loan A: interest + points + fees$468,734
Loan B: interest + points + fees$430,804
Months for B's lower payment to repay its extra up-front cost31
  1. P=pmt⁡(350,000,6.751,200,30×12)=2,270.09
  2. Pay=pmt⁡(350,000,6.251,200,30×12)=2,155.01
  3. I=2,270.09×30×12−350,000=467,233.6
  4. In=2,155.01×30×12−350,000=425,803.67
  5. C=467,233.6+350,000×0100+1,500=468,733.6
  6. Co=425,803.67+350,000×1100+1,500=430,803.67
  7. D=468,733.6−430,803.67=37,929.93

Loan B saves (+) or costs (−) over the full term $37,930

Each step uses the unrounded value of the step before it; figures on this page are rounded for display.

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth paying points on a mortgage?

When you keep the loan past the break-even month. In the example, one point ($3,500) for 6.25% instead of 6.75% pays for itself in 31 months.

Should I compare APRs too?

Yes. The APR on each Loan Estimate folds points and fees into one yearly rate, which makes offers with the same term easy to compare.

Questions answered

Related calculators