Skip to content
FiftyCalc Free calculators for all 50 states

New vs Used Car Calculator

Test cases replayed : 2 of 2 match · Methodology · No outside source listed

Enter the price, financing, expected resale value and yearly costs of each car and how long you will keep it to see which one costs less overall.

Result

Sample figures

Result—

New car monthly payment —

  • Used car monthly payment—
  • New car: total cost over the period—
  • Used car: total cost over the period—
  • New car: cost per year—
  • Used car: cost per year—
  • Difference—

Estimate for planning only, not tax, legal, financial or medical advice. This calculator uses the method explained on this page.

New vs Used Car Calculator

Years you will keep the car: enter a number from 1 to 15. Prefilled example: 5.

New car: price, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 38,000.

New car: down payment and trade-in, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 5,000.

New car: loan APR, in percent: enter a number from 0 to 40. Prefilled example: 6.5.

New car: loan term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 96. Prefilled example: 60.

New car: expected value when you sell, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 19,000.

New car: insurance, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,800.

New car: maintenance and repairs, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 500.

Used car: price, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 24,000.

Used car: down payment and trade-in, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 5,000.

Used car: loan APR, in percent: enter a number from 0 to 40. Prefilled example: 8.5.

Used car: loan term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 96. Prefilled example: 60.

Used car: expected value when you sell, in dollars: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 12,000.

Used car: insurance, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,500.

Used car: maintenance and repairs, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more. Prefilled example: 1,200.

How to use this calculator

Fill in the fields in this order; each step takes you to its field.

  1. Years you will keep the car: enter a number from 1 to 15.
  2. New car: price, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  3. New car: down payment and trade-in, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  4. New car: loan APR, in percent: enter a number from 0 to 40.
  5. New car: loan term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 96.
  6. New car: expected value when you sell, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  7. New car: insurance, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more.
  8. New car: maintenance and repairs, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more.
  9. Used car: price, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  10. Used car: down payment and trade-in, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  11. Used car: loan APR, in percent: enter a number from 0 to 40.
  12. Used car: loan term, in months: enter a number from 1 to 96.
  13. Used car: expected value when you sell, in dollars: enter 0 or more.
  14. Used car: insurance, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more.
  15. Used car: maintenance and repairs, in dollars / year: enter 0 or more.
  16. Read the result: Result; the panel also shows New car monthly payment, Used car monthly payment, New car: total cost over the period, Used car: total cost over the period, New car: cost per year, Used car: cost per year and Difference.

How this calculator works

Monthly payment = standard amortization formula on the amount financed (price − down payment) at the APR ÷ 12 over the term.

Cost over the period = down payment + the payments made while you own the car + the loan balance still owed when you sell (B = P(1 + r)^k − M((1 + r)^k − 1) ÷ r after k payments) − the resale value + years × (insurance + maintenance).

Sales tax, registration, fees and fuel are left out: add them to the price or the yearly costs if they differ between the two cars. Resale values are your estimate; check current listings for similar cars of the age they will be.

Worked example

Years you will keep the car5
New car: price$38,000
New car: down payment and trade-in$5,000
New car: loan APR6.5%
New car: loan term60 months
New car: expected value when you sell$19,000
New car: insurance$1,800 / year
New car: maintenance and repairs$500 / year
Used car: price$24,000
Used car: down payment and trade-in$5,000
Used car: loan APR8.5%
Used car: loan term60 months
Used car: expected value when you sell$12,000
Used car: insurance$1,500 / year
Used car: maintenance and repairs$1,200 / year
New car monthly payment$645.68
Used car monthly payment$389.81
New car: total cost over the period$36,241
Used car: total cost over the period$29,889
New car: cost per year$7,248
Used car: cost per year$5,978
ResultThe used car costs $6,352 less over 5 years

Frequently asked questions

Why can a new car cost more overall?

When the new car loses more value while you own it, that loss can outweigh its lower interest rate and repair costs. A used car can cost more in repairs and interest. The calculator weighs all of these with your numbers.

What if I keep the car longer than the loan?

Then every payment is counted and nothing is owed when you sell.

Should I include my trade-in?

Yes, add it to the down payment of the car you would buy with it.

Questions answered

Related calculators